I don't understand the comparison either. So a while back, after driving AMS2 quite a bit, I thought I'd try PC2 just to see if I was right (the mind can play games, so wanted to be sure). Now I hadn't played PC2 for a while as I found it felt a bit odd, graphically beautiful, but odd. Straight away they felt like different games, AMS2 had a nice comfortable feeling (perhaps a little too comfortable) and PC2 still felt odd in comparison (still fun, of sorts, though). I think the main differentiator is the FFB, and in AMS2 it is almost as good as rF2 (where I do most of my league racing). Somehow, PC2 still feels ever so slightly better than AMS2 graphically, but the difference is small and you tend not to notice that while racing anyway. AMS2 easily beats rF2 graphically, though there are a few rF2 tracks that are plenty good enough, and S397 seem to be working on the eye candy of late. I think the criticism probably stems from us humans being quite tribal, so we tend to like what we like and criticise all else, even if it makes little sense. There are fanboys everywhere, even here!